Violence at Unity Center for Behavioral Health Draws Financial Questions

Critics say financial incentives influenced the center’s decision to use a "living room style" of intake area which critics say invites attacks.

Greg Monaco worked with people experiencing psychotic episodes as a pre-commitment investigator for 30 years.

But when the Unity Center for Behavioral Health opened in Northeast Portland in February 2017, Monaco was shocked by the fear among staff and state of the patients.

Inebriated patients in a crowded room thrashed and yelled. Some patients were undermedicated.  Others were restrained unnecessarily, he said. He watched a security guard put a female patient in a choke hold, causing another caregiver to gasp. At least two patients died while he was there. In the spring, one patient died, then on July 11, a suicidal woman hung herself.

Much of the chaos, he said, stemmed from the center’s “living room” style patient intake area, also known as the Psychiatric Emergency Services or “the PES.”

“Believe me,” Monaco said. “You would not want yourself or any of your loved ones in the PES.”

The Unity Center for Behavioral Health is at risk of losing its federal certification and reimbursements from Medicare & Medicaid after a state investigation discovered the death of one patient, at least one instance of sexual assault, negligence and a long list of other ongoing safety hazards.

Five mental health professionals told The Lund Report in the past few days that they were not surprised by the violence. They said its open-plan model for patient care invited attacks. A large part of the problem, they said, likely stemmed from the financial incentives to centralize care.

“The size was daunting to provide the safe environment for staff and for patients,” said Tim Murphy, CEO of Bridgeway Recovery Services, a mental health and addiction care center in Salem.

In a statement last week Brian Terrett, spokesman for Legacy Health, said: “Our number one priority at Unity Center for Behavioral Health has always been, and will always be, the safety and well-being of our patients and our staff. We take the Oregon Health Authority’s investigation very seriously and are working vigorously to address every area of concern and to ensure the safety our patients and employees.”

A ‘Terrifying’ Care Model

The Unity Center opened in February 2017 as a collaboration among four of Portland’s major health organizations. Adventist Health, Kaiser Permanente, Legacy Health and Oregon Health & Science closed their individual psychiatric departments and opened the Unity Center as a central destination for patients experiencing a mental health crisis.

The center implemented a model of care developed in Alameda County, California, to help psychiatric patients get quick help. Instead of going to a traditional emergency room, with limited psychiatric beds, patients are taken to a center specialized in dealing with health care crises. At Unity, they’re placed in one large room with about 50 recliner chairs, where they are evaluated by a psychiatrist and attended to by caregivers. They can stay there for as many as 23 hours before being moved to a private room or released into the community. They share their private psychological details in an open room with no privacy curtains shielding them from other people.

“You could be a depressed person who entered there and could be next to someone who is psychotic,” Monaco said. “People found it terrifying.”

The last place a person experiencing a psychotic episode wants to be is around other people in mental distress, said another mental health worker who has experienced mental health crises. That person, who requested anonymity because the individual does work with Unity, said that a patient in crisis needs to be in a safe, stable environment where they're not at risk of getting pulled into someone else's delusion.

The setting put both patients and staff at risk, Monaco said. Staff shared stories about worker injuries with Monaco, including a time that a social worker got two black eyes after a patient pummeled the worker to the ground when there was no security around to help. Another patient ended up stepping in to help, Monaco said.

Two former nurses sued the Unity Center in February for more than $1 million each. They claimed that the center fired them after they complained about safety concerns, including assaults and serious injuries. One lawsuit noted that an Oregon Occupational Safety and Health Administration investigation found hundreds of assaults. One lawsuit was dropped, but the other is ongoing.

“It’s the organization’s responsibility to provide a sense of safety for the staff who work there and the people receiving care,” said Tim Murphy, the Salem mental health and addiction services provider. “Not until safety is experienced by both recipients of care and providers can true treatment and healing begin.”

Culture Clashes

A lack of clear protocols made an unsafe situation even more chaotic, Monaco said. Unity staffers who came from Adventist Health, Kaiser Permanente, Legacy Healthy and Oregon Health & Science each brought with them different care philosophies.

Some were quicker to restrain patients to avoid staff injuries, while others believed in giving patients space to express their frustrations, even if they were loud or disruptive, he said.

Monaco reported his concerns to his supervisors at the Multnomah County Health Department. He said his boss told him that what he reported was not the county’s liability and therefore not their problem.

Multnomah County spokeswoman Julie Sullivan-Springhetti told The Lund Report in a statement that the county has launched an internal audit of its procedures for dealing with complaints. It will report those findings to its partner agencies and the broader public.

“Our community has a profound need for immediate, 24-hour psychiatric care for people experiencing a mental health crisis,” she said. “ The County takes these concerns very seriously.”

Monaco then wrote to Unity’s vice president Chris Farentinos in a May 2017 email obtained by The Lund Report. He encouraged her to talk to her staff members from Adventist who had told him that “Unity represents a 10-year setback in patient care.” Staff felt alienated, he told her.

“The bringing of the cultures together under the Unity umbrella is the biggest challenge ahead,” Farentinos wrote back in an email obtained by The Lund Report. “And some of the staff came in with practices that are misaligned to our vision.”

“Our leadership team is working diligently on planning and implementing a culture development plan that over time will bring our Unity staff much more in alignment with a trauma informed, recovery and patient centered culture,” she added.

Throughout May, Monaco sent several follow up emails to Farentinos, including one about a patient who he felt was experiencing “abusive” treatment. His bosses told him to stop contacting Farentinos.

Farentinos did not respond to a request for comment.

Legacy Health spokeswoman Julie Reed instead sent a statement responding defending Unity’s care model.

“The model of care at Unity Center seeks to deinstitutionalize acute psychiatric care and treat those in crisis with respect and dignity,” Reed said in an email Monday. “We believe in this approach and are committed to the success of Unity Center. We are working diligently to address challenges and continue to make progress on our action plan.”

Reed did not answer questions about Unity’s care model, finances or the number of filled beds.

Concentrated Risk

While the opening of Unity centralized emergency psychiatric care, it also concentrated risk by limiting patients’ care options.

“When Unity was created, they put most of their eggs in one basket,” said Bob Nikkel, a board member at the Foundation for Excellence in Mental Health Care and Oregon’s former commissioner for mental health and addiction.

Now, Unity is one of two places to go for patients experiencing a mental health crisis. The other is Providence St. Vincent Medical Center, which saw an increase in admissions after Unity abruptly stopped accepting patients transferred by law enforcement, medics and other hospitals.

Cedar Hills Hospital also offers mental health services, but only takes patients based on certain criteria. Patients must be “actively suicidal,” homicidal or unable to care for themselves in order to get admitted to inpatient care, Cedar Hills CEO Libby Hutter said in an email. The hospital has 94 inpatient beds and usually more than 90 percent of them are filled, Hutter said.

Unlike Unity, Cedar Hills separates patients into different units based on specific behaviors and needs. They have a crisis unit for patients who have difficulty controlling their behavior and a separate psychiatric unit for depressed patients who are not acting out, Hutter said.

“Our organization believes it is best for patients to participate in specific programming that is focused on their psychiatric or addiction issues,” Hutter said. She declined to comment on Unity’s different model.

The Unity Center has more than 100 beds, which puts all of those beds at risk should the center fail.

A Money-making Model?

Nikkel was among five mental health officials who questioned whether the high costs of mental health influenced the four hospitals’ decision to fold their services into a larger facility.

Personnel are the most expensive part of running a hospital, they said. Mental health facilities require around-the-clock care, which means paying for providers adds up quickly, regardless of the facility’s size. Meanwhile, providers are typically only able to bill Medicare and Medicaid per patient bed, they said.

Centralizing care enables health-care facilities to hire a larger pool and to receive more reimbursements due to the increased number of beds.

Monaco said that financial decisions likely also impacted Unity’s care model. He said perhaps two psychiatrists told him the system was an important part of the funding stream. It allows the hospital to bill for the time that patients spend in the emergency services area in addition to billing for the time they spend in an inpatient bed, he said.

Murphy, the Salem mental health care provider, said he could not speak to Unity’s financial situation, but said that mental health care gets more expensive every year.

“When there is a lot of budget pressure, that’s when staff-to-patient ratios go down, corners are cut, patients start to feel less safe and conflicts arise,” he said.

The Investigation

The Oregon Health Authority has been investigating Unity since it received a complaint about patient safety in February. The state regulator announced last week that it found “deficiencies” at the Unity Center for Behavioral Health that “jeopardize patient safety.”

Among many problems listed in a 105-page report obtained by The Lund Report, the investigation found:

  • At least 23 patients experienced “actual or alleged” abuse or neglect.
  • Patients at risk of self-harm were given pencils and pens, rigid plastic utensils, shaving razors, cords, pillow covers, string and scrub pants and other items they could use to hang or smother themselves.
  • One patient with a history of cutting was given a razor to use while “supervised” in the shower and cut themselves.
  • Another patient escaped the facility by following a vendor with a badge off the property. Others ran away during “supervised garden time.”
  • The facility did not mitigate risks associated with sloped doors, hinges on the tops of doors and gaps between horizontal grab bars on walls that could increase risk of hanging or binding, the report said.
  • Patients lacked adequate supervision when in high-risk or vulnerable areas. Majority of patient rooms had “blind spots” in camera views that included places where hanging was a risk.
  • The hospital had no written process for responding to emergency situations. Emergency medical devices such as oxygen tanks, blood glucose meters and wound dressing supplies were not consistently stored or available in times of emergency.
  • Patients’ rights were not protected or promoted when restrained or isolated. The staff who restrained or secluded patients were not properly trained.

Uncertain Future

The hospital corrected several of the most glaring issues in May after state investigators put the facility on notice.

They removed plastic utensil dispensers from patient units, closed gaps on grab bars and locked patients’ bathroom doors when not used by a patient under staff supervision.

Unity also established policies for preventing patients from running away and planned to conduct “environmental safety rounds” twice a day where they check for safety hazards. It ordered carts stocked with emergency medical supplies and placed them in all units.

Terrett shared a plan of correction describing steps the center plans to take in order to address the problems described in the report. The 77-page document includes plans to retrain its nursing staff, evaluate hanging risks and other hazards in the building and better document patient emergencies.

“During our first year of operation, like any new entity, we have identified opportunities for improvement,” Terrett said in last week’s statement. “We have worked diligently to specifically address all of the issues raised…We have made significant progress and will continue to make changes in both our physical environment and our practices.”

The center has until Sept. 11 to correct the problems described in the Oregon Health Authority investigation. If it fails to do so, it could lose its certification.

“They could conceivably be shut down,” Monaco said. “Then what would happen?”

Reach Jessica Floum at [email protected].

Corrections: The living-room style PES at Unity Center does not have privacy curtains and a social worker, not a nurse, was clobbered. The Lund Report regrets the errors.